Judgments news
Court rulings and reported decisions on arbitration, mediation and related dispute resolution matters.
Bombay High Court Rejects Arbitration in Government Employee Medical-Reimbursement Dispute
Aadrikaa Legal Services (ALS)- Law I Litigation I Arbitration This Short Article has been prepared & written by Arbitrator Shobhit Malik. He can be reached at his mob no- +91 9712924188 and email id shobhit.Ica23@gmail.com . The Bombay High Court has quashed an arbitration award directing The…
Top Weekly Legal Developments India: 2-8 November 2026 | SCC Times
This roundup of weekly legal developments in India highlights significant Supreme Court and High Court rulings, including the Supreme Court’s clarification on the applicability of OBC creamy layer criteria to concluded selections and UPSC CSE 2025 service allocation, its decision permitting green…
High Court of Judicature at Bombay Upholds Petitioner in Arbitration Dispute — Award Challenged for Pervasiveness and Inconsistency.
The case involved a challenge to an arbitral award issued under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, by the Kolhapur Municipal Corporation against Fairdeal Construction. The dispute arose from an agreement for the collection of octroi duty, where the respondent was appointed as an agent. The…
Mutual Consent Must Precede Arbitrator Appointment Under Conditional Clause: Kerala High Court
The Kerala High Court, on 3 November, held that a party cannot invoke arbitration where the dispute resolution clause makes arbitration conditional on fresh mutual consent, and the parties have not reached such an agreement .
Supreme Court Dismisses Appeal Against Arbitration Award in Construction Dispute — Upholds Arbitrator's Findings.
The dispute arose from a construction contract between the U.P. Cooperative Federation Ltd. and M/s Three Circles for a cold storage project. The contract included clauses regarding arbitration and the authority of the Managing Director to resolve disputes. After the project was delayed, the…
The Urbajet Award on State Consent and Construction Losses
The arbitration between Urbajet Sarlau (“Urbajet”) and the Republic of Equatorial Guinea (“Equatorial Guinea”), administered by the International Chamber of Commerce (“ICC”), illustrates both the strength of a State’s agreement to arbitrate and the evidentiary limits of contractual compensation. In…
Three Fabricated Contracts, One Closed Door: Bahari v Azerbaijan
On 21 September 2026, an arbitral tribunal (the “Tribunal”) rejected the investment claims brought by Mohammad Reza Khalilpour Bahari (“Mr. Bahari”), an Iranian investor, against the Republic of Azerbaijan (“Azerbaijan”). The Tribunal accepted jurisdiction over part of the dispute but held that…
Amazon Seller Services Dispute Referred to Sole Arbitration by Karnataka High Court
Aadrikaa Legal Services (ALS)- Law I Litigation I Arbitration This Short Article has been prepared & written by Arbitrator Shobhit Malik. He can be reached at his mob no- +91 9712924188 and email id shobhit.Ica23@gmail.com . The Karnataka High Court has appointed retired District Judge Sri Mohan S.…
Bengaluru ADR Week 2026 to be held from November 13 to 15 - Bar and Bench
The third edition of Bengaluru ADR Week will be held from November 13 to 15, 2026, with judges, senior advocates and arbitration practitioners from India and abroad expected to participate in the three-day conference. The conference, organised by the Bengaluru ADR Week Organising Committee, will…
High Court of Judicature at Bombay Allows Appeal in Arbitration Matter — Interim Relief Granted to Secure Admitted Debt.
The dispute arose between a Singapore-based company and an Indian company regarding an unpaid debt of USD 66,92,500. The Appellant filed a Section 9 Petition under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, seeking interim protection before the constitution of an Arbitral Tribunal, which was…
Stock Market Highlights: US stocks rebound, but Nasdaq posts fourth straight weekly decline
The case stems from a Fourth Circuit ruling that denied Goldman Sachs' bid to compel arbitration in a lawsuit brought by Apple Card account holders, with the majority ruling that arbitration inherently conflicts with the centralized purpose of bankruptcy law. The Supreme Court's decision will…
BREAKING: High Court Will Take Up Case Of Goldman Arbitration Denial
The U.S. Supreme Court agreed to take up a case involving a Fourth Circuit decision that denied an attempt by Goldman Sachs to arbitrate disputes with two debtors in bankruptcy over alleged violations of the automatic stay .
International Arbitration: English Court of Appeal Upholds High Court Ruling that ICSID Awards Cannot be Assigned | Akin
In a judgment handed down on Monday, ... from November 2025 that arbitration awards made pursuant to the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) Convention are not capable of assignment....
Same Arbitrator Can Hear Multiple Disputes Under Same Contract: Supreme Court
Summary: The Supreme Court in Panipat Jalandhar NH-1 Tollway Private Limited Vs National Highways Authority of India examined whether an arbitral tribunal comprising an arbitrator who had been appointed on multiple occasions by the same party could adjudicate further disputes arising from the same…
Supreme Court Upholds Award in Arbitration Dispute Over Water Supply Contracts — Clarifies Interest Entitlement.
The dispute arose from the 'Bhavnagar City Water Supply Scheme' initiated by the Gujarat State Government in 1978, with contracts awarded to the respondent for construction work. Following allegations of underpayments, the respondent filed a civil suit in 1981, which was later withdrawn to pursue…
Supreme Court Upholds Appellant's Challenge in Arbitration Act Case — Clarifies Court's Role Post-Arbitral Tribunal Constitution.
The dispute arose from a Cargo Handling Agreement between the Appellant and Respondent, which included an arbitration clause. After invoking arbitration, the Appellant approached the High Court for the appointment of an Arbitral Tribunal. The Respondent contested the arbitrability of the disputes…
Absence Of Signature On Credit Card Application Does Not Mean No Arbitration Agreement, But Bank Must Show Customer Accepted Its Terms: Bombay High Co
Law does not require signatures of both parties, but Bank cannot bind a person to its arbitration clause without material showing acceptance, the Bench noted and found a prima facie acceptance in clause treating use of card as acceptance.
Punjab and Haryana High Court Sets Aside Removal of Manju Rana as Permanent Lok Adalat Chairman
Manju Rana was appointed Chairman of the Permanent Lok Adalat, Kapurthala, in June 2017.
HC quashes removal of Kapurthala Lok Adalat Chairperson, says defence closed without recording witnesses
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has set aside the removal of the Chairperson of Permanent Lok Adalat (Public Utility Services), Kapurthala, whose defence was closed despite two listed witnesses' statements not having been recorded. The bench ruled that a Permanent Lok Adalat Chairperson could not…
Widen Pool From Which Arbitrators Are Drawn To Include Qualified Women & Technical Experts: Gujarat High Court
Taking note of the dearth of women arbitrators and technical experts, the Gujarat High Court has suggested widening the pool from which arbitrators are drawn. The High Court was of the view that such underrepresentation merits due representation. The High Court made such observations while dealing…